The cultural phenomenon of Stranger Things did more than just dominate the pop culture conversation; it rekindled a global love affair with 80s nostalgia and sci-fi horror. Its blend of small-town mystery, government conspiracies, and endearing characters proved to be a winning formula. But if you’ve binged every season and are left with a Demogorgon-sized void in your viewing schedule, you’re in luck. The landscape of science fiction and fantasy is vast and deep, filled with brilliant, under-the-radar stories that offer similar—and often even more complex—thrills.
As a dedicated sci-fi and fantasy analyst and critic with over a decade of experience dissecting genre narratives, I’ve curated a list of seven exceptional gems you likely missed. This selection isn’t just a random assortment of shows; it’s a carefully considered guide based on narrative depth, world-building ingenuity, and emotional resonance. We’ll move beyond mere recommendations to explore why each of these works stands as a masterpiece in its own right, worthy of your time and attention.
Forget the algorithms for a moment. Let’s dive into the worlds of mind-bending time travel, haunting cosmic horror, and dark urban fantasy that you’ve been searching for.
1. Dark (Netflix)
The Premise: In the small German town of Winden, the disappearance of two children opens a Pandora’s box of secrets, connecting four estranged families. The search uncovers a time travel conspiracy that spans several generations, involving a local nuclear power plant and a mysterious cave system. This isn’t just a mystery; it’s a sprawling, intergenerational tragedy where the past, present, and future are inextricably linked.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: While Dark gained a cult following, its German-language origin and intensely complex plot caused many to shy away. It is, without exaggeration, one of the most meticulously crafted narratives in television history. It makes Stranger Things‘ timeline look straightforward. The show operates on a deterministic model of time travel where every action is both a cause and an effect, creating a tragic, inescapable loop for its characters.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Antithesis of Nostalgia: Where Stranger Things uses the 80s as a warm, comforting blanket, Dark uses its time periods (spanning from the 1880s to the 2050s) to explore the haunting weight of the past. The 80s in Winden are not about cool bikes and Dungeons & Dragons; they are a period of hidden trauma, environmental anxiety (post-Chernobyl), and familial breakdown.
- Character as Consequence: The character development is unparalleled. A young, sympathetic character in one timeline might be the embittered, morally compromised villain in another. Understanding the connections—”Who is who’s father/grandmother/son?”—is a puzzle in itself, but it’s a puzzle that serves a profound theme: the sins of the fathers are truly visited upon the children.
- A Complete, Perfect Loop: Unlike many shows that falter in their final seasons, Dark sticks the landing with breathtaking confidence. Its three-season arc was clearly planned from the start, resulting in a conclusion that is both intellectually satisfying and emotionally devastating. It’s a masterclass in narrative payoff.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The small-town mystery and interconnected family dramas of Stranger Things, but crave a more challenging, philosophically dense, and adult-oriented story.
2. The Leftovers (HBO Max)
The Premise: On October 14th, 2% of the world’s population—140 million people—instantly and inexplicably vanishes. This is not the Rapture of the faithful; it’s a random, senseless event. The series picks up three years later, focusing on the people left behind in Mapleton, New York, and beyond, as they grapple with a world shattered by grief and the search for meaning in a world that no longer provides any.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: The Leftovers is less a traditional sci-fi mystery and more a profound character study draped in a supernatural premise. It famously abandoned the central “why?” of the Sudden Departure early on, choosing instead to ask, “How do we live now?” The result is a raw, surreal, and often bizarre exploration of grief, faith, and madness that is unlike anything else on television.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Grammar of Grief: The show invents its own language for coping. The Guilty Remnant, a cult that wears white and takes a vow of silence, embodies numb, nihilistic remembrance. Holy Wayne, a self-proclaimed prophet who can hug people’s pain away, represents the desperate need for absolution. The series doesn’t judge these responses; it simply observes them with a haunting empathy.
- Tonal Mastery: The Leftovers seamlessly shifts from gut-wrenching drama (the season two opener, “Axis Mundi,” is a standalone masterpiece) to absurdist black comedy (an international departure-themed sex cult, a hotel where people can literally forget their lives). This tonal bravery allows it to capture the disorienting and irrational nature of profound loss.
- A Triumph of Emotional Truth: While the plot is often ambiguous, the character emotions are razor-sharp. The performances, particularly by Justin Theroux and Carrie Coon, are career-defining. The series argues that in the face of the unexplainable, the only thing that matters is the truth of human connection.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The emotional core of Stranger Things—the grief of a lost child (Will Byers), the fracturing of a community—but want to see that concept explored with unflinching, artistic maturity.
3. Station Eleven (HBO Max)
The Premise: A devastating flu pandemic wipes out most of the world’s population. The narrative weaves between the immediate aftermath of the collapse and a future, twenty years later, where a nomadic troupe of actors and musicians called the Traveling Symphony roams the Great Lakes region, performing Shakespeare for surviving settlements. Their motto: “Survival is insufficient.”
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: In a post-2020 world, a pandemic story might seem like a tough sell. But Station Eleven is the antithesis of a grim, nihilistic apocalypse. It is a breathtakingly beautiful and hopeful meditation on the endurance of art, memory, and community. It’s not about the world that ended, but about the fragile, beautiful one that was built from its ashes.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- Art as Survival Mechanism: The series posits that in the absence of modern medicine, government, and technology, the human spirit is sustained by stories. The performances of Shakespeare are not a frivolous hobby; they are essential rituals that help people process trauma, remember beauty, and re-learn what it means to be human.
- Non-Linear Storytelling as Healing: The show’s structure, which jumps between multiple timelines and perspectives, isn’t just a narrative gimmick. It mirrors the process of memory and trauma recovery. We only understand the full picture of the characters’ lives and the post-apocalyptic myth of the “Prophet” by piecing together fragments from the past and present.
- The Antidote to Toxicity: A central conflict involves a cult-like figure who preaches that one must “forget the past.” The Traveling Symphony, and the series itself, argues the exact opposite: we must carry the past with us, not as a burden, but as a guide. It’s a profoundly humanist and optimistic vision.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The focus on kid-led adventures and the power of friendship in Stranger Things, but are looking for a more poetic, literary, and ultimately hopeful take on rebuilding after catastrophe.
4. Counterpart (Starz)
The Premise: Howard Silk is a low-level bureaucrat in a dusty UN agency in Berlin. He discovers that his agency is a front for a gateway to a parallel reality, created during a Cold War experiment. This other world is identical to ours, but with diverging histories. Our Howard is meek and overlooked; the “Other” Howard is a ruthless, calculating spy. When a dangerous operative crosses over, the two Howards must reluctantly work together.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: A spy thriller with a sci-fi conceit, Counterpart was critically acclaimed but never found a mass audience, partly due to its platform (Starz). It is a masterclass in acting and world-building, using its dual reality premise not for flashy action, but for a deep, philosophical exploration of identity, choice, and regret.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Cold War, Eternal: The central conflict is a “Cold War” between the two worlds, but it’s deeply personal. Our world, the “Alpha” world, is softer, more decadent. The “Prime” world is harder, more disciplined, having endured a devastating flu. The series uses this to explore the paths not taken, both for individuals and for civilization.
- J.K. Simmons’ Tour de Force: Simmons plays both Howards, and his performance is nothing short of miraculous. He doesn’t rely on tricks; he embodies two distinct souls. You can tell which Howard is on screen from his posture, his vocal cadence, and the look in his eyes. It’s a acting clinic that elevates the entire series.
- A Meditation on the Self: Counterpart asks the essential question: “Who would I be if one key moment in my life had gone differently?” It delves into nature vs. nurture with stunning intelligence, showing how our experiences, our loves, and our losses forge our identity.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The Cold War tension, espionage elements, and the concept of the Upside Down as a dark reflection of our world in Stranger Things, but want a more sophisticated, character-driven, and espionage-focused narrative.
5. The Expanse (Amazon Prime Video)
The Premise: A few hundred years in the future, humanity has colonized the Solar System but remains deeply divided among a resource-strapped Earth, a militant Martian Republic, and the “Belters”—the impoverished inhabitants of the Asteroid Belt and outer planets. The discovery of a mysterious alien protomolecule throws this fragile cold war into chaos, as a hard-boiled detective, a rogue ship captain, and a UN executive find themselves at the center of a conspiracy that threatens all of human existence.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: While it now has a dedicated fanbase (that famously saved it from cancellation), The Expanse remains one of the most under-appreciated mainstream sci-fi shows. It is the heir to Battlestar Galactica‘s throne, a “hard sci-fi” political thriller that treats its universe with ruthless realism and intellectual consistency.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Physics is a Character: In The Expanse, there is no artificial gravity. Ships accelerate to create gravity, flip, and decelerate. People born in low-gravity environments (Belters) have distinct physiologies and can’t survive on Earth. Battles are fought with realistic physics, involving long-range missiles and point-defense cannons. This commitment to realism makes the world feel tangible and dangerous.
- The Best Political Sci-Fi Since Game of Thrones: The alien mystery is the catalyst, but the heart of the show is the complex political maneuvering between Earth, Mars, and the Belt. It’s a profound allegory for colonialism, class struggle, and resource scarcity. The OPA (Outer Planets Alliance) is not a monolithic entity; it’s a fractured movement with moderates, radicals, and terrorists, much like real-world independence movements.
- Evolution of a Universe: The series masterfully scales up. It begins as a noir detective story, expands into a solar system-wide political conflict, and gradually unveils a mind-bending cosmic horror threat that challenges humanity’s place in the universe. It earns every step of its expansion.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The sense of a vast, unfolding mystery and the high-stakes sci-fi concepts in Stranger Things, but want a more politically complex, adult, and scientifically grounded epic.
6. Patriot (Amazon Prime Video)
The Premise: John Tavner is a deep-cover intelligence officer suffering from severe depression and PTSD. To prevent Iran from going nuclear, he is given a non-official cover: as a mid-level employee at a Milwaukee industrial piping firm. His mission: befriend a key figure and influence a Luxembourg-based industrial bid. His method: writing and performing melancholic folk songs about his classified life.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: Patriot is the most difficult show on this list to categorize—and the most uniquely brilliant. It’s a spy thriller, a black comedy, a workplace drama, and a heartbreaking study of clinical depression, all rolled into one. Its tone is a singular blend of deadpan humor, surreal bureaucratic nightmares, and profound human sadness.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Bureaucracy of Espionage: The show is less about glamorous spycraft and more about the soul-crushing absurdity of modern intelligence work. John’s mission is a Rube Goldberg machine of convoluted, fragile steps. A single misplaced piping catalog can jeopardize global security. This captures a hilarious and terrifying truth about complex systems.
- Folk Music as Therapy: John’s folk songs are not a gimmick; they are his only outlet for processing his trauma. The lyrics are literal descriptions of his missions and pain, sung to people who hear them as quirky metaphors. It’s a devastatingly effective narrative device that underscores his isolation.
- A Chain of Kindness: Beneath the cynicism and violence, Patriot is a deeply empathetic show about damaged people trying to be “double-great” for each other. It argues that in a cold, mechanical world, the only thing that keeps us sane is the small, consistent kindness we offer one another.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The blend of dry humor and genuine character struggle found in characters like Steve Harrington or Jim Hopper in Stranger Things, but are looking for something utterly original, tonally daring, and deeply melancholic.
Read more: From Indie Darling to A-List Star: The Meteoric Rise of Paul Mescal
7. The Bureau (Le Bureau des Légendes) (Sundance Now/Canal+)
The Premise: A deeply immersive, realistic look into the lives of France’s external intelligence service, the DGSE. The series follows “The Bureau of Legends,” the department that runs deep-cover agents (“legends”) in non-friendly countries. The focus is on Guillaume “Malotru” Debailly, a brilliant agent who returns to Paris after six years undercover in Syria and struggles to readjust to his real identity, all while managing a new agent and reckoning with a dangerous past connection.
Why It’s a Gem You Missed: Hailing from France, The Bureau is widely considered by intelligence experts and critics to be the most authentic spy show ever made. It’s a slow-burn, meticulously detailed procedural that forgoes car chases and gunfights for the real tools of espionage: psychological manipulation, bureaucratic wrangling, and digital hacking.
Deep Dive & Analysis:
- The Psychology of Identity: The core of the show is the psychological damage of living a lie. Malotru is a ghost, unable to fully inhabit either his real identity or his discarded cover. This leads him to make reckless, emotionally-driven decisions that put entire networks at risk. The series is a terrifying study of how undercover work erodes the self.
- The “Slow Horse” Mentality: Unlike the mission-of-the-week format of American spy shows, The Bureau is a novelistic, serialized story. Operations take seasons to unfold. Setbacks are devastating and permanent. The tension is derived not from physical danger, but from the constant, gnawing fear of a single misstep, a single compromised email, leading to exposure and death.
- Unrivaled Authenticity: The show’s creators consulted extensively with former intelligence officers. The tradecraft—from dead drops and surveillance detection routes to the complex jargon and office politics—feels unnervingly real. It’s a masterclass in verisimilitude.
Perfect For Viewers Who Loved: The tension and high-stakes secrecy of the Hawkins Lab storyline in Stranger Things, but crave a hyper-realistic, adult, and psychologically complex look at the world of secrets and lies.
Conclusion: Your Next Favorite World Awaits
The magic of Stranger Things is undeniable, but it exists within a rich ecosystem of genre storytelling that dares to be more challenging, more nuanced, and more artistically ambitious. The seven gems listed above are not just shows to watch; they are worlds to inhabit, puzzles to solve, and emotional journeys to undertake. They prove that the best sci-fi and fantasy isn’t about escape, but about reflection. They use the fantastic as a lens to examine the most profound human questions about time, grief, identity, and connection.
So, power up your streaming device, but this time, venture beyond the algorithm’s safe suggestions. Travel to the rain-slicked streets of Winden, the grieving towns of The Leftovers, or the politically charged void of The Expanse. You’ll find that the void left by the Demogorgon was just the beginning of a much larger, and far more fascinating, universe.
Read more: Hollywood’s Hottest Feuds: The On-Set Clashes That Shaped Film History
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: I see Dark is in German. Should I watch it dubbed or with subtitles?
A: As a purist, I strongly recommend watching it in the original German with subtitles. The dubbed version, while serviceable, loses the nuance and emotional weight of the actors’ original performances. The cadence of their speech, their whispers, and their cries are a vital part of the storytelling. Reading subtitles becomes second nature within the first episode and ensures you experience the show as the creators intended.
Q2: Several of these shows, like The Leftovers and Patriot, seem really depressing. Are they without any hope?
A: This is an excellent and important question. While these shows grapple with heavy themes like grief, depression, and existential dread, they are not nihilistic. In fact, their power lies in how they find glimmers of light, connection, and even humor within the darkness. The Leftovers is ultimately about learning to live and love again after unimaginable loss. Patriot is a tragicomedy that finds profound humanity and absurd humor in its protagonist’s suffering. They are emotionally demanding, but their conclusions are often cathartic and deeply hopeful, just in a more earned and complex way than traditional narratives.
Q3: I tried The Expanse but found the first few episodes slow and confusing. Does it get better?
A: Yes, unequivocally. The world-building in the first season of The Expanse is notoriously dense. There’s a lot of jargon (like “beltalowda” and “inner”) and many factions to keep track of. Most fans point to a specific moment around episode 4, “CQB,” as the point where the show “clicks” and the throttle opens up. If you can push through the initial setup, you will be rewarded with one of the most thrilling and consistent sci-fi epics ever made. Consider the early episodes an investment.
Q4: Why isn’t [Insert Popular Show like Black Mirror or Westworld] on this list?
A: Great question. The goal of this list was to highlight shows that are truly underrated or missed by the mainstream audience that loved Stranger Things. Shows like Black Mirror and Westworld are already massive, award-winning phenomena with widespread recognition. The selections here are critically acclaimed but have not achieved the same level of popular saturation and are therefore more likely to be “gems you missed.”
Q5: From a production standpoint, which of these shows is the most similar to Stranger Things in terms of pacing and vibe?
A: If you’re looking for the most direct tonal and pacing counterpart, Dark is your answer, albeit in a much darker and more complex key. It shares the central premise of kids disappearing in a small town, triggering a supernatural mystery that involves local history and a time-bending threat. For a closer match in emotional vibe—specifically the focus on hope, friendship, and rebuilding—Station Eleven, despite its post-apocalyptic setting, captures that heartfelt, character-driven spirit.
