Kangana Ranaut’s much-anticipated film ‘Emergency’ has hit a major roadblock. The Censor Board has asked for 13 specific cuts and changes before granting the film a U/A certificate for its release. This has led to a delay in the release of the film, which was initially planned for September 6. The situation has sparked a tussle between the filmmakers and the Censor Board, as Kangana, both the director and lead actor of the film, had earlier expressed her strong desire to release the movie without any cuts.
The film, which delves into the Emergency period in India’s history, has come under scrutiny due to its portrayal of historical figures and certain sensitive topics. While the Censor Board has given the film a U/A certificate, the release is still uncertain as the makers decide on the necessary edits.
Kangana’s Stand on Releasing the Film Uncut
Kangana Ranaut has made it clear in past interviews that she intends to release the film in its original, uncut version. In one of her earlier statements, she boldly declared, “I will fight in court and get the film released without cuts.” This strong stance came into question as the Bombay High Court recently intervened in the matter, raising concerns about the content of the film. The Censor Board has demanded that 13 changes be made before the movie is allowed to hit theatres.
Despite Kangana’s previous stand, the co-producers of the film, Zee Studio, have requested some time to deliberate on the suggested changes. With a new court hearing scheduled for September 30, the fate of the film’s release hangs in the balance.
What Edits Has the Censor Board Asked For?
The Censor Board has raised objections to multiple scenes in the film, which it believes could lead to controversy, particularly about sensitive historical and political topics. Below are some of the key changes demanded by the board:
- Adding a Disclaimer: The board has asked the filmmakers to include a disclaimer at the start of the film, clarifying that it is “inspired by true events” and is a “dramatic adaptation”. This would make it clear that the events depicted are not meant to be taken as literal historical facts.
- Jawaharlal Nehru Dialogue: In one of the early scenes of the film, a dialogue by former Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru states that “China has separated Assam from India.” The Censor Board has asked the filmmakers to provide the source of this claim, as the historians on the board do not recall such an incident.
- Bhindranwale and Sanjay Gandhi Dialogue: At 1 hour and 52 minutes into the film, a scene shows Bhindranwale telling Sanjay Gandhi, “Your party wants votes, we want Khalistan.” The Censor Board has objected to this dialogue, requesting its removal, as it suggests a deal between the two. The board has also asked for evidence supporting this statement.
- Sikh Violence: A scene at 2 hours and 11 minutes shows Sikh characters committing violence against non-Sikhs. The board has requested this scene to be toned down, as it may be seen as controversial by viewers.
- Sikhs Firing at Non-Sikhs: Another scene that has raised concerns shows Sikhs firing at non-Sikhs in front of a bus. The board has demanded the complete removal of this scene, citing it as potentially offensive.
- Mention of ‘Arjuna Day’: In a discussion between Indira Gandhi and the Army Chief regarding Operation Bluestar, there is a mention of the term “Arjuna Day,” referring to the martyrdom anniversary of Guru Arjan. The Censor Board has asked for this term to be removed, as it does not align with Sikh religious traditions.
- Bhindranwale’s Name: The board has also objected to the mention of Bhindranwale’s name in three different scenes, even in instances where the character is not shown on screen. They have instructed the filmmakers to remove his name from these dialogues.
- Real Footage Static Message: The film uses real historical footage in some parts. The Censor Board has requested that a static message be added to these sections, clarifying that the footage is being used for dramatic purposes.
- Evidence for Data and Statements: The filmmakers have been asked to provide documentary evidence for all the data, statements, and historical references made throughout the film.
The Debate Between Filmmakers and the Censor Board
With 13 specific cuts being requested, the team behind ‘Emergency’ is in a tight spot. Zee Studios, the co-producers, have requested more time to think over the edits, while the High Court had earlier urged the Censor Board to decide by September 25. As of now, the next hearing has been set for September 30, giving the filmmakers some extra time to negotiate and possibly resolve the issue.
While the Censor Board is firm on its stance to protect public sensibilities, the filmmakers must decide whether to comply with the cuts or continue the legal battle to release the uncut version. Kangana Ranaut’s strong stance on maintaining the film’s integrity without any edits adds further complexity to the situation.
Why is ‘Emergency’ Facing Such Intense Scrutiny?
‘Emergency’, directed by Kangana Ranaut, explores the controversial Emergency period in India’s history, a time when civil liberties were suspended, and the government exercised extraordinary powers. The film portrays several key political figures, including Indira Gandhi, Sanjay Gandhi, and Bhindranwale, all of whom are central to the film’s narrative.
The Emergency period remains a highly debated and sensitive topic in Indian politics. Any film that tackles this subject is likely to face scrutiny due to its potential to reignite past controversies. In this case, the portrayal of Bhindranwale and his interactions with political figures like Sanjay Gandhi has drawn the attention of various groups, especially from the Sikh community.
Several scenes and dialogues have been flagged by the Censor Board as potentially controversial, especially in their representation of Sikh leaders and Operation Bluestar, an operation that continues to have emotional and political significance.
Will the Film’s Release Be Delayed Further?
The release date of ‘Emergency’ remains in limbo. Although it was originally slated for a September 6 release, the ongoing discussions and required edits could push the release date further. For now, the filmmakers await the next hearing, hoping for a resolution that satisfies both the Censor Board and the creative team behind the movie.
The uncertainty surrounding the film’s release continues to captivate audiences, with many eager to see how this standoff between Kangana Ranaut and the Censor Board unfolds.
